Legislation to prevent the state from taxing forgiven mortgage debt cleared the state Assembly early Monday, offering potential tax relief to thousands of Californians who lost their homes in 2009.
"The feds don't do it and we're not going to do it, either," Assemblyman Charles Calderon, D-Montebello, said Monday before a 47-27 vote that sent the measure to Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.
Schwarzenegger's office signaled later that he may veto the measure. The governor opposes an unrelated provision in SBX8 32 concerning tax refunds sought by corporations.
"Our position hasn't changed," said Schwarzenegger spokesman Mike Naple.
The Assembly vote ratified earlier state Senate approval of a measure that aligns many California tax codes with those of the federal government. One clause would eliminate state tax penalties for those who received loan modifications last year or did short sales. In loan modifications, lenders sometimes forgive a few months of payments. In short sales, they agree to sales prices below what they're owed to avoid foreclosing. The differences in both are considered forgiven debt for the homeowner and typically taxed as extra income.
Vacaville homeowner Mark Mosley said Monday he received a $21,000 tax bill last week for a $59,000 loan modification he received in 2009. He said his lender notified him he owes $13,000 to the federal government and $9,000 to the state.
It's almost certain, however, that Mosley doesn't owe federal taxes. The federal government has banned the IRS from taxing forgiven mortgage debt through the end of 2012. The state government had similar bans in place for the 2007 and 2008 tax years. But it hasn't yet extended the ban to the 2009 tax year.
While every homeowner's case can be different, typically those who live in the homes they own can avoid being taxed for forgiven debt. Lawmakers called it a fairness issue Monday, arguing that people having mortgage hardships shouldn't also get hit with a big state tax bill.
"We should provide relief to those who are struggling and at risk of losing their homes," said Assemblywoman Mariko Yamada, D-Davis.
Schwarzenegger opposes a clause that penalizes businesses for seeking some tax refunds. Businesses say it's often hard to calculate what they owe the state, and thus, overpay to avoid stiff penalties. But Democrats say some companies unfairly seek state tax refunds that they aren't owed.
--Call The Sacramento Bee's Jim Wasserman, (916) 321-1102 or email him at [email protected]. Read his blog on real estate, Home Front, at www.sacbee.com/blogs.